In 2009, I became extremely concerned with the concept of Unique Identity for various reasons. Connected with many like minded highly educated people who were all concerned.
On 18th May 2010, I started this Blog to capture anything and everything I came across on the topic. This blog with its million hits is a testament to my concerns about loss of privacy and fear of the ID being misused and possible Criminal activities it could lead to.
In 2017 the Supreme Court of India gave its verdict after one of the longest hearings on any issue. I did my bit and appealed to the Supreme Court Judges too through an On Line Petition.
In 2019 the Aadhaar Legislation has been revised and passed by the two houses of the Parliament of India making it Legal. I am no Legal Eagle so my Opinion carries no weight except with people opposed to the very concept.
In 2019, this Blog now just captures on a Daily Basis list of Articles Published on anything to do with Aadhaar as obtained from Daily Google Searches and nothing more. Cannot burn the midnight candle any longer.
"In Matters of Conscience, the Law of Majority has no place"- Mahatma Gandhi
Ram Krishnaswamy
Sydney, Australia.

Aadhaar

The UIDAI has taken two successive governments in India and the entire world for a ride. It identifies nothing. It is not unique. The entire UID data has never been verified and audited. The UID cannot be used for governance, financial databases or anything. It’s use is the biggest threat to national security since independence. – Anupam Saraph 2018

When I opposed Aadhaar in 2010 , I was called a BJP stooge. In 2016 I am still opposing Aadhaar for the same reasons and I am told I am a Congress die hard. No one wants to see why I oppose Aadhaar as it is too difficult. Plus Aadhaar is FREE so why not get one ? Ram Krishnaswamy

First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win.-Mahatma Gandhi

In matters of conscience, the law of the majority has no place.Mahatma Gandhi

“The invasion of privacy is of no consequence because privacy is not a fundamental right and has no meaning under Article 21. The right to privacy is not a guaranteed under the constitution, because privacy is not a fundamental right.” Article 21 of the Indian constitution refers to the right to life and liberty -Attorney General Mukul Rohatgi

“There is merit in the complaints. You are unwittingly allowing snooping, harassment and commercial exploitation. The information about an individual obtained by the UIDAI while issuing an Aadhaar card shall not be used for any other purpose, save as above, except as may be directed by a court for the purpose of criminal investigation.”-A three judge bench headed by Justice J Chelameswar said in an interim order.

Legal scholar Usha Ramanathan describes UID as an inverse of sunshine laws like the Right to Information. While the RTI makes the state transparent to the citizen, the UID does the inverse: it makes the citizen transparent to the state, she says.

Good idea gone bad
I have written earlier that UID/Aadhaar was a poorly designed, unreliable and expensive solution to the really good idea of providing national identification for over a billion Indians. My petition contends that UID in its current form violates the right to privacy of a citizen, guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution. This is because sensitive biometric and demographic information of citizens are with enrolment agencies, registrars and sub-registrars who have no legal liability for any misuse of this data. This petition has opened up the larger discussion on privacy rights for Indians. The current Article 21 interpretation by the Supreme Court was done decades ago, before the advent of internet and today’s technology and all the new privacy challenges that have arisen as a consequence.

Rajeev Chandrasekhar, MP Rajya Sabha

“What is Aadhaar? There is enormous confusion. That Aadhaar will identify people who are entitled for subsidy. No. Aadhaar doesn’t determine who is eligible and who isn’t,” Jairam Ramesh

But Aadhaar has been mythologised during the previous government by its creators into some technology super force that will transform governance in a miraculous manner. I even read an article recently that compared Aadhaar to some revolution and quoted a 1930s historian, Will Durant.Rajeev Chandrasekhar, Rajya Sabha MP

“I know you will say that it is not mandatory. But, it is compulsorily mandatorily voluntary,” Jairam Ramesh, Rajya Saba April 2017.

August 24, 2017: The nine-judge Constitution Bench rules that right to privacy is “intrinsic to life and liberty”and is inherently protected under the various fundamental freedoms enshrined under Part III of the Indian Constitution

"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the World; indeed it's the only thing that ever has"

“Arguing that you don’t care about the right to privacy because you have nothing to hide is no different than saying you don’t care about free speech because you have nothing to say.” -Edward Snowden

In the Supreme Court, Meenakshi Arora, one of the senior counsel in the case, compared it to living under a general, perpetual, nation-wide criminal warrant.

Had never thought of it that way, but living in the Aadhaar universe is like living in a prison. All of us are treated like criminals with barely any rights or recourse and gatekeepers have absolute power on you and your life.

Announcing the launch of the # BreakAadhaarChainscampaign, culminating with events in multiple cities on 12th Jan. This is the last opportunity to make your voice heard before the Supreme Court hearings start on 17th Jan 2018. In collaboration with @no2uidand@rozi_roti.

UIDAI's security seems to be founded on four time tested pillars of security idiocy

1) Denial

2) Issue fiats and point finger

3) Shoot messenger

4) Bury head in sand.

God Save India

Showing posts with label NN - Election Candidature. Show all posts
Showing posts with label NN - Election Candidature. Show all posts

Friday, September 27, 2013

4646 - Nandan Nilekani 3.0: From entrepreneur to 'plumber' for govt, and now, to a change initiator - Economic Times

By Soma Banerjee, ET Bureau | 19 Sep, 2013, 06.46AM IST

What is not clear in Nilekani’s case—and this is not in his hands alone—is the shape this greater political participation could take.

On a hot May afternoon in the capital this year, when Nandan Nilekani walked into South Block to meet Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, unique identity cards and cash transfers were on his mind. The ruling UPA had publicly staked its political future on these two projects, whose creator and keeper was Nilekani, and such meetings with the prime minister had become routine. That meeting turned out to be anything but routine. 


Singh asked Nilekani, a rare hand in his cabinet who was not a member of either house of Parliament, to change that in the near future, says an aide of Singh privy to the meeting. Nilekani responded with his disarming smile. 

The prime minister's words came out of the blue that day. But for Nilekani, that idea—to join the hurly burly of politics to try and achieve bigger things—had been swirling in his mind for close to a year. And, as always, the pull for him was the idea of being a changemaker and finding what he describes as the "next level in my story of change". 

That story has seen him graduate from employee to entrepreneur, from IT industry captain to a technocrat in the government in charge of transformational projects. And now, possibly, probably, politics. 

Nilekani, 58, is clear he wants to play a larger role in governance. "The choices at this stage are clear," he told ET. "Getting into the mainstream and becoming one who can initiate change for the larger public good." He also recognises the conventional and respectful road in the space he wants to operate in flows through greater political participation. "You need political energy and political support to execute any change," he adds. 



What is not clear in Nilekani's case—and this is not in his hands alone—is the shape this greater political participation could take. In the space in which Nilekani wants to exist, there are, broadly speaking, three options. 


One, stay a technocrat, as he has been since 2009, when he was handpicked by Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi to lead a project to issue unique identity numbers to every Indian. Two, come in as a member of the Rajya Sabha, which does not require a mandate from the people, and be a minister like Jairam Ramesh or even Manmohan Singh. Three, in what will be the most challenging personally and professionally for Nilekani, a member of the Lok Sabha, elected by the people. 

Nilekani, blessed with a disposition for risk and also the makeup to manage it, is said to be leaning towards elections, representing the Congress Party from a constituency in Bangalore—home to Indian IT and the city he calls home. "It is a great signal that he is willing to enter politics by contesting elections and not as a Rajya Sabha member, which is normally the route taken by entrepreneurs businessmen and professionals," says Deepak Parekh, a doyen of Indian industry. "It shows courage and conviction." 

Even as he lists the many upsides of Nilekani being in the political system, TV Mohandas Pai, a former colleague at Infosys, says the Congress needs to win for Nilekani to give true expression to what he wants to do by joining politics. "Say, Nandan wins, but the Congress loses," says Pai, chairperson of the board of Manipal Global Education. "Then, what does he do except for making some good Parliament speeches for five years?"

Whichever option he chooses, Nilekani is seeing it as part of a continuum and inclined. "My journey so far has progressed from being an ideator, which I was when I wrote the book on ideas that made India and some of the anticipated ones too. Next, the doing part, with the UID database," he says. "Now, the question is of being the change initiator, doing what needs to be done." 

POLITICAL DYNAMICS 

Ravi Bapna, who has known Nilekani for about five years and has worked with him on UIDAI projects, is not surprised by Nilekani's likely move towards greater political participation. "His story is that of transformation," says Bapna, a professor at the University of Minnesota. "In a representative democracy, true power resides, and rightly so, with the elected, as opposed to the appointed." 

Milind Deora, a young minister in the UPA cabinet, sees Nilekani make an easy transition. "He has the skills to negotiate change and build consensus, and also understands how political parties are run," he says. 

Yashwant Sinha, who left the civil services to join politics, too endorses Nilekani's move. "Successful professionals can only enrich politics when they join it," says Sinha, a BJP leader and a former finance minister. "Every party should encourage more professionals to come into the political fold." 


According to Deora, the Congress has been in discussions with professionals from other fields who could cross over, including Nilekani, for some time. "We have always believed in getting different stakeholders and people from diverse backgrounds into the polity," he says, citing the example of Shashi Tharoor, a career official at the United Nations who contested on a Congress ticket in 2009 and won. 

While the popular reading is that Nilekani too would choose the Congress, he is guarded in his response but reveals enough. "The party and the ideology do matter to what I believe in and my nature of work," he says. "My background speaks for my work. I come from a background that has believed in a secular, liberal, inclusive, empowered environment." 
Back in 2009, when prime minister Singh asked him to join the government—which meant leaving Infosys, where he was serving as the co-chairman of its board of directors— it was an easy choice for Nilekani at that stage.


In 2007, he finished a five-year term as CEO of Infosys, a tenure in which its revenues grew five-fold, and Nilekani cemented his reputation as a leader with a knack of getting the job done. "He has a logical mind, driven with data," says Pai. "He listens to all stakeholders, but has the capacity to take decisions." 

Increasingly, around the time his executive duties with Infosys were tailing out, he was veering into public policy. For example, he became a member of the National Knowledge Commission, formed by the prime minister to reform higher education in India. "There was no hesitation in my mind as I had always dreamt of this," he told ET in 2011, of Singh's offer. "As a child, I had watched my father and uncle closely, and heard family conversations on public policy."

STEEP LEARNING CURVE 

After a ringside view of policymaking in those panels, the last four years at the helm of the Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI) have seen him in the ring, trying to push through change in a system, with multiple stakeholders. 

At times, he's been on the offence. At times, he's been on the defence. At times, he's been collateral damage. All this in spite of being backed by the highest echelons in the government (the prime minister) and the Congress Party (Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi). 

Nilekani joined UIDAI at a cabinet rank. Its mandate was to assign a unique identity number, called Aadhaar, to every Indian by 2017, and this would eventually become the reference number for all kinds of transactions. Gradually, UIDAI's remit widened to also cover financial inclusion, targeted subsidies and cash transfers to beneficiaries." It was a reflection of the faith the UPA leadership was willing to place in him. "The bonus with him is that he gets the transformative power of technology intuitively, and with a scale and scope that is unparalleled," says Bapna. 

As of August 30, UIDAI had issued 420 million Aadhaar numbers, alternating between enthusiastic expression and identity crisis. The crisis stemmed from a disagreement between two government's ministries—finance and home, then led by Pranab Mukherjee and P Chidambaram, respectively—on who should do these enrolments and how. 

January 2012, to forge a truce. And it took a political realisation on the UPA's part, in mid-2012, for the government to take a singular view on Aadhaar and cash transfers, and push hard, together. "His stint as UIDAI chairman and his dealings with various states have prepared him extremely well for anything that lies ahead," says Bapna. 

When talking about wheels of change, a phrase that is a refrain with Nilekani is "consensus building". He feels it is more difficult to build consensus in public policy than in the corporate world, where the stakeholders are fewer. "It's on a larger scale, from government ministries to bureaucrats to think-tanks to political parties, auditors," he says. "You have to use different motivations and policies to navigate the differences among stakeholders." 

Despite his corporate background, Nilekani demonstrates a nuanced understanding of the political economy, and a patient resolve to engage with it. "The first thing I did when I took over was to go to every state and meet the chief minister and the chief secretary," he says. "Having them on board was crucial and reaching out to them was important politically too." 

He is willing to subscribe to its rules, but is also constantly looking for openings to subtly sell his ideas. "My three main learnings from the UIDAI project have been: keep the solution simple; design it such that it comes across with more enhancements for the stakeholder and not something that can disturb their turf; and reach out, articulate and communicate."

Professor Deepak Pathak, who taught Nilekani at IIT Bombay in the seventies, has seen early signs of that political bent of mind. "He became the general secretary of the students union at IIT, not an easy task," says Pathak. "He has always believed in the India story and I have found him to be keen to work on projects that would serve a larger good." 

That desire and urgency to serve a larger good has seen Nilekani and his wife, Rohini, give away hundreds of crores of their personal wealth—which Forbes estimates at $1.3 billion (about Rs 9,000 crore), as of March 2013, largely from their Infosys shareholding—to educational institutions, and organisations that work to address some of the basic human needs. Some of this thinking is influenced by Nilekani's father, Mohan Rao, a manager in a textile company and a Nehruvian. 

LARGER POLITICAL CHANGE 

Embedded in Nilekani's move towards greater political participation, likely via elections, is the wider point of how accomplished leaders from other fields joining politics could change the nature of the polity. 

In recent times, Meera Sanyal, former chief executive of Royal Bank of Scotland India, stood in the 2009 general elections from South Mumbai. As did Captain GR Gopinath, founder of Air Deccan, from Bangalore. Both lost. "But, as of now, this (professionals entering politics) is episodic," says Yogendra Yadav, member of the Aam Aadmi Party and a political commentator. "They have not been able to make an impact on the body politics." 

Compared to Sanyal and Gopinath, Nilekani is seen to have a higher public profile and represents the highest of ethics. He is also seen as a man who has earned his spurs in the government and understands its workings. "Nandan will be a symbol of the aspirational Indian, the India that wants to dream, own a house and drive a car," says Pai. "Unfortunately, the Congress worships the poor and wants to perpetuate it. They are bound to target him." 

Yadav gives the highest endorsement to Nilekani's likely crossover, saying his party would readily give him a ticket as he ticks every box to be its candidate. "Politics needs people with the highest virtues," he says. 

At the same time, Yadav is wary of reading this as being a catalyst for a larger shift. "Isolated entries may not be the way to change the system," he says. "Meenakshi Natarajan of the Congress is very honest person with highest credentials. But what is not known is whether her entry has made a change in the honesty quotient of the Congress Party." 

Yadav would like to see Nilekani contest polls, rather than take the Rajya Sabha route. "It will speak of his commitment as this will help him soil his hands, connect with millions of people, deal with numerous issues," he says. "This will give the political legitimacy he would want to have to represent people." Adds Parekh: "He will have to forget his Saturdays and Sundays, and get down to canvassing.

"

4645 - Is he joining Congress? Nilekani says 'possibly' - Express News Service


Express News Service : Bangalore, Mumbai, Thu Sep 19 2013, 01:58 hrs

Is he joining Congress? Nilekani says 'possibly'

Express news service Posted online: Thu Sep 19 2013, 01:58 hrs

Bangalore, Mumbai : Nandan Nilekani (58), head of the Unique Identity project, is likely to join Congress and contest the 2014 Lok Sabha election as part of a party strategy to counter Narendra Modi with a line-up of credible candidates. Those who know him well said he was considering the prospect seriously. Asked if he was joining Congress, Nilekani said: “Possibly”.

If he does contest the election, Nilekani would become the first Indian to make the turnabout from a successful corporate big wheel to an important government functionary to a politician. His industry colleagues doubted his lasting power but Nilekani deftly manoeuvred himself through the labyrinth of Delhi politics and has endeared himself to politicians and chief ministers across parties.

He has been approached as Congress desperately needs accomplished candidates to boost its image and attract the huge number of first-time urban voters. “Fielding Nilekani will send the right signal not just to Bangalore but all of urban India,” a Congress leader said.

Nilekani is said to be in the inner circle of Congress president Sonia Gandhi and her son Rahul, and is reportedly also close to PM Manmohan Singh.

He certainly has the standing, having co-founded Infosys and spearheaded the gamechanging technology initiative to provide biometric identities to billion-plus Indians. When he was CEO of Infosys in the 1990s, he headed Bangalore Agenda Task Force to improve infrastructure of the city with the state government. In 2009, the billionaire quit the Infosys board to head the UID scheme.

Nilekani does not figure on a short list of candidates for the three Lok Sabha constituencies in Bangalore being prepared by the Karnataka Pradesh Congress Committee (KPCC) but has been discussed at the party high command level, insiders said.

“The state list for Bangalore North, South and Central constituencies does not feature Nilekani. But he is in a different category that is the high command’s prerogative,” sources in Karnataka Congress said.

The candidature of Nilekani was definitely on the table for the Bangalore South seat that has a large number of IT workers and had been discussed at the highest level, if not in the state, they said.

Among the reasons Nilekani is being considered is that he “does not need introduction, he is urban and fulfills caste combination requirements’’, the sources said.

4644 - Nilekani’s candidature a rumour: KPCC chief - The Hindu


SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT

Karnataka Pradesh Congress Committee (KPCC) president G. Parameshwara has termed reports about Unique Identification (UID) Project chairperson Nandan Nilekani being his party’s choice to contest from Bangalore South in the Lok Sabha elections as a “rumour”.

“I have heard about this only through the media. These reports are based entirely on rumours. There is no such move. Any recommendation has definitely not gone from us,” he said here on Wednesday.

Denying that Mr. Nilekani’s name emerged as a probable candidate during the observers’ meeting recently, Dr. Parameshwara said: “I am not aware from where this report has emerged. It appears like it has been planted from Delhi. There is no material in it. I would have known if there had been something like that.”

Although the party had decided to field in the Lok Sabha elections only those who have been Congress members for at least three years, Dr. Parameshwara admitted that there could be “some exceptions”. He added that this did not mean that Mr. Nilekani would be the candidate.

Rumours have been doing the rounds in the last two days that Mr. Nilekani’s candidature was being considered by the party for the Bangalore South Lok Sabha constituency.

There were even reports that All India Congress Committee vice-president Rahul Gandhi was interested in fielding Mr. Nilekani.

Keywords: Nandan Nilekani, Unique Identification Project, Lok Sabha elections, Bangalore South constituency, KPCC president G. Parameshwara


4643 - Cong to field India Inc darling Nandan Nilekani against Modi? - First Post

Sep 18, 2013



Just days after BJP elevated Narendra Modi as the party’s prime ministerial candidate, it seems billionaire Nandan Nilekani, cofounder of outsourcer Infosys, is preparing for a full time career in politics. The former Infosys chief executive officer and chairman of the Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI) might be considering taking a plunge into electoral politics by joining the Congress to contest the forthcoming Lok Sabha election. The constituency is likely to be from Bangalore, Karnataka, Nilekani’s home state which is also a constituency dominated by “upper-class professionals. Media reports suggest Congress wants to leverage Nilekani’s clean image to woo urban voters away from BJP nominee Narendra Modi. Congress leaders are reportedly hoping that by fielding Nilekani, the party can garner the votes of not only India’s corporates but also the educated class. “”Getting elected by popular vote will give him the extra legitimacy that needs to make a difference as a technocrat-politician”, a senior Congress leader was quoted as saying by the Economic Times. According to a report in the Telegraph, “Nilekani could embody quite another political appeal, a tug to India’s burgeoning and aspirational middle class being wooed away from the UPA on the back of a recurrent campaign of policy paralysis, economic stagnation and financial downturn…The Congress could well see in Nilekani — author of the bestselling road-ahead treatise Imagining India — a man who could espouse a contrary worldview of the “New India” to the BJP’s Narendra Modi.”


Mint has termed Nilekani’s decision to enter politics as both brave and welcome. “Electing the likes of Nilekani is the first step towards  clearing the air… The ensuing political vacuum has been filled, at one level by the judiciary (not a solution that will work in the long term), and at another, by technocrats such as Nilekani (but since they have not been elected, their legitimacy will always be in doubt). More importantly, their accountability is indirect, something that should be avoided in a democratic framework. Expertise is welcome in government, but elected experts are always preferable to appointed ones, says Mint. Here’s all you need to know about Nandan Nilekani:  1. The  billionaire entrepreneur  and an IIT-Mumbai alumnus, quit the board of Infosys in 2009, after nearly three decades with the company, to head the UIDAI, an ambitious government project to provide an identity number to every resident Indian. The project is touted as one of UPA’s notable successes as UIDAI has issued over 400 million identity cards to date and Nilekani recently said that he’s confident that by 2014 every other Indian will have one. The 12-digit Aadhaar card is already being used to open bank accounts and for transfer of cash entitlements, among  other things. 2. According to a report in Times of India, Nilekani was sounded out by Congress general secretary Rahul Gandhi a couple of months ago, as the task of setting up, launching and evangelizing the Aadhaar cards was now over and the question arose over Nilekani’s future. Nilekani was drafted by the Manmohan Singh government to devise and pilot  Aadhaar in 2009.  He was also given the rank of a cabinet minister. And if he must enter  politics, he will have to quit his current cabinet-rank job. Reports also said that Nilekani enjoys a ‘great’ rapport with both party chief Sonia Gandhi and vice-president Rahul Gandhi. Moreover even though Nilekani’s UID project faced several bureaucratic challenges, the general perception has been that Nilekani had shown toughness in  face of such opposition. 3. If the UIDAI chief enters the electoral bandwagon, he will be the first technocrat from India’s  IT industry to test the waters of direct politics. 4. Nilekani has a home in the posh Koramangala area that is part of the Bangalore South constituency. This seat is currently held by  BJP’s Ananth Kumar. Kumar is a five-time sitting MP. According to a report in Asian Age  Kumar is expected to be shunted to second-tier city and his hometown Hubli as the RSS is pushing for popular cricketer Anil Kumble in a bid to ensure that at least 18-20 seats of the 28 from Karnataka are mopped up by the BJP. 5. Nilekani also co-founded Nasscom and is associated with think tanks like NCAER ( the premier independent applied economics research institute in India) and  Indian Council for Research on International Economic Relations (ICRIER). He also sits on several advisory boards, including those of the World Economic Forum Foundation and the Bombay Heritage Fund. 6. According to Forbes, Nilekani has an estimated net worth of $1.3 billion and is the 53rd richest India

Thursday, September 26, 2013

4624 - Neta Nilekani is fine, but I still wouldn’t buy his Aadhaar by R Jagannathan - First Post

Sep 18, 2013



The morning’s papers are awash with speculation about Nandan Nilekani, Chairman of the Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI), fighting the next Lok Sabha elections on a Congress ticket. Since there is no smoke without fire, one can assume that the speculation is reasonably founded in fact. Good luck to him in his career. However, there’s nothing surprising about it. Nilekani has been doing the UPA’s dirty work of shoving a quasi-illegal Aadhaar card down our throats in the name of empowering the poor. If an articulate and intelligent man like Nilekani can push such a major initiative without any law backing it and still survive the political challenges, he is surely half a politician already. Given the Congress’ good showing in Karnataka recently, Nilekani is probably home and dry even before the battle for votes begins. Let’s also not forget. Nilekani faced challenges from many parts of the government, from the Planning Commission, the finance ministry and the home ministry. If he still survived such a formidable challenge, surely he is cut out for politics.

Nilekani is the chairman of the Aadhaar card project. Reuters


Nilekani is the kind of guy I could have voted for, but I am not sure I would want to take his Aadhaar card. I prefer Neta Nilekani to Nilekani the UID vendor. Since the two are the same, I can’t ultimately vote for Nilekani either. 

Nobody should be under the illusion that Aadhaar is any kind of boon conferred on us by Nilekani. It is a Trojan horse gifted by a dysfunctional government which will ultimately compromise our security without even a fig leaf of statutory protection for our privacy. It has been sold as a means to reach government benefits to the poor, but it could well end up as one more tool in the hands of the powerful to exclude some and extract speed money from the rest. 

There are many reasons why I don’t think Nilekani has done us a favour with Aadhaar. First, of course, is its questionable legality. There is no law which authorises anyone, even if the PM has told him to do so, to take the Indian citizen’s most prized possession – his identity, his biometrics, his fingerprints – and pretend he is doing him a favour. Morally and ethically, no one should do this without having a law guaranteeing adequate protection against misuse of the data collected. There is no such assurance to Indian citizens that their fingerprints will not fall in the wrong hands. 

Second, the idea of keeping an entire population’s biometric and personal details – every man, woman and child living in the territory of India, even if not a citizen – in huge databases is scary. Some 1,210 million people will stand exposed when UIDAI is completed. No country has ever done this for unstated purposes, though the US does so for social security, and has strong laws protecting people against misuse. If Hitler wanted a tool to control his people, he could not have asked for a better weapon than the UID database. 

Third, the scheme is being sold as a way to empower the poor who don’t have an identity but need government subsidies to survive. But it is being covertly pushed to the entire population. It is being pushed steadily by using the coercive power of the bureaucrat’s pen to make Aadhaar critical for all basic needs. If bank accounts, provident funds, mutual funds, gas connections, and almost any financial transaction by any citizen are going to need an Aadhaar number, this means the government has forced a unique ID on us indirectly without even legally being entitled to do so. If this is not a Trojan horse, what is? 

Fourth, today all kinds of private parties are being used to collect finger-prints and iris biometrics. If the collection of private data is in private hands at the start, what is to prevent this data from remaining in private hands illegally? 

Remember, at some point the idea is to use Aadhaar numbers to validate identity for financial transactions. But if my Aadhaar information is with a private party, will Nilekani guarantee that I cannot be impersonated? And if it does happen, who will protect me? The banks, which are being pressured to use Aadhaar numbers? 

Fifth, the real economic purpose of Aadhaar is to cut out fake and duplicate beneficiaries of government subsidies. This is a good reason to use the Aadhaar. However, in practice, this will increase bribery and corruption on an unimagined scale. Since no politician wants to lose any vote by specifically excluding the middle class or the non-poor from receiving subsidies, the chances are Aadhaar will be improperly used. To prevent exclusion from subsidies, everyone from gas dealers to power suppliers will seek bribes to ensure you continue to be subsidised. It is only a matter of time before politicians and middlemen figure out how to use Aadhaar to enrich themselves. 

Sixth, extortion will become easier. Once your income-tax numbers, bank accounts, credit card transactions, and asset purchases are linked through a common Aadhaar number, anyone in any part of a coercive tax system can blackmail you if your assets and financial details are leaked, you will be vulnerable. Remember, the whole 2G scam was unveiled when the Radia tapes were illegally leaked. Today, laws are in place to listen to every mobile conversation you make, every website you visit, and every transaction you conduct. 

Enter Aadhaar, and the ability of the establishment to connect all your conversations and transactions will magnify 10-fold. Do we want to be that vulnerable? 

Seventh, the collective wisdom of the parliamentary standing committee on finance clearly warned against the UIDAI. It vetted the UPA’s National Identification Authority of India Bill 2010 and recommended that it be trashed and replaced with something better. A report in India Today said the committee “strongly disapproved” of the “hasty manner” in which the scheme was being implemented, and pointed out that the data could be “misused”. (Nilekani, incidentally, is the man hastening Aadhaar. The report said: “The committee has questioned the technology used in Aadhaar.” It questioned the “technology as ‘unreliable and untested’. It has also cited the experience of foreign countries with similar schemes and said that many European nations withdrew their UID projects after opposition from the public.” This is not to say that Nilekani was brought in specifically to intrude into citizens’ privacy. Neither Manmohan Singh nor Nilekani could have had that thought in mind when they started out with Aadhaar. 

But during the course of the last five years it should have been obvious to Nilekani that the original purpose was going to be compromised in the minefield of politics. None of this also means that we don’t need an Aadhaar. 

There are, and can be, many legitimate uses for the Aadhaar number. But there is little doubt about its current dangers. Should Nilekani have gone ahead and still done the job without ensuring citizen safeguards and a legal backing? It is quite possible that Nilekani was sold a pup by the UPA. But should he have then sold the pup to us, in turn? He is already part of a messy political compromise where the integrity of the citizen’s privacy is now up in the air. Maybe he will fix the problem once he is elected and gets to take Aadhaar forward. But no one can bet on that any more. I, for one, would not like to get myself an Aadhaar number.

Wednesday, September 18, 2013

4609 - Nandan Nilekani may contest elections on Congress ticket - Live Mint

Nilekani is likely to contest the next Lok Sabha elections from South Bangalore


Regardless of the outcome, Nandan Nilekani’s move (if it happens) may just accelerate a transformation in Indian politics. Photo: Pradeep Gaur/Mint

Updated: Wed, Sep 18 2013. 01 21 AM IST

There is nothing official about it yet, but the buzz in Lutyens Delhi has it that Nandan Nilekani is poised to enter politics and contest the next Lok Sabha elections from South Bangalore on a Congress ticket.

Nilekani did not respond to messages, but three people independently confirmed that both the head of the Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI) and the Congress party were thinking along these lines.

The constituency is currently represented by the Bharatiya Janata Party’s (BJP’s) Ananth Kumar, although there has been talk in Bangalore that the BJP, which lost power to the Congress in the May assembly elections in Karnataka, could field former Indian cricket captain Anil Kumble for this seat. Mint couldn’t independently verify this.

If Nilekani does contest, it will be a brave decision, and well-timed.

Regardless of the outcome—he does stand a good chance of succeeding—Nilekani’s move (if it happens) may just accelerate a transformation in Indian politics.

For one, it comes as a breath of fresh air. For a host of reasons, politicians, like the media, have lost their credibility as a tribe. This is tragic, because it is not and cannot be that all politicians are bad. It is just that the narrative, in the backdrop of corruption scandals and governance failure, has become so bleak that a trust deficit is inevitable. Electing the likes of Nilekani is the first step towards reversing this unhealthy trend and clearing the air.

Second, the ensuing political vacuum has been filled, at one level by the judiciary (not a solution that will work in the long term), and at another, by technocrats such as Nilekani (but since they have not been elected, their legitimacy will always be in doubt). More importantly, their accountability is indirect, something that should be avoided in a democratic framework. 

Expertise is welcome in government, but elected experts are always preferable to appointed ones.

Third, Nilekani brings to the table a tremendous skill set that is carefully camouflaged by his understated style. Even before he took charge of the ambitious Aadhar project to provide every resident of India with a unique identification number, he had more than proved his mettle as a manager, strategist, and project leader at Infosys Ltd, a software company put together in 1981 by a bunch of enthusiastic technocrats who believed as much in themselves as in the opportunity they perceived.

Fourth, the man has proved ably during his present tenure in government that he can work in and around an existing system; very few of us have the patience to operate from within to inspire change.

A little over a year ago, his project ran into turbulence after it got caught in the crossfire between rival ministries and ministers. Nilekani did not lose heart and kept making his case to the power-that-is and the power-that-may-be. 

Eventually, he got his way. Those, even in the Congress, who were badmouthing him, turned into supporters overnight—to such an extent that the direct benefit transfer scheme that rides on the Aadhar programme is now being openly touted by Congress functionaries as a vote-catching initiative.

Nilekani’s decision to get his hands dirty in the murky world of Indian politics is both brave and welcome.